|
Criss-Crossings : S.H. Raza and Manish Pushkale
No introduction is necessary for Sayed Haider Raza or the Progressive Artists Group, Bombay, of which he was a founder member in 1947. For decades now, Raza's work has gained national and international recognition for his attempts to revitalize Indian philosophical thought in art. Three years ago, he set up the Raza Foundation in New Delhi, to scout young artistic talent, recognize and encourage their pursuits by initiating a dialogue, exchange ideas and share forums. Raza believes that younger emergent talents from India are making significant contributions, placing Indian painting on the world map while rooted in their history and consciousness. The Raza Foundation issues two awards each year, a form of empowerment to an aspiring artist/painter and a writer/poet, whose works exhibit self-driven personal convictions and historical consciousness.
This exhibition shows no strains of generational conflict as it celebrates the coming together of two generations of artists - Manish Pushkale, a 2002-3 awardee, who at 30 is developing a vision of his own with S.H.Raza, 83, who is arriving at simplicity after almost 60 years of work. The common denominator in their artistic practice is the shared inspiration from homegrown philosophies and indigenous artistic sources. Raza is enthusiastic about sharing the platform with a new generation, " I am very keen to walk with the younger generation, share their creative energies and space…and it is sheer delight to look at the works of Seema Ghurraya, Smriti Dikshit, Sujata Bajaj and Manish…the vitality is incredible…"
Looking back, Raza's journey is far from ordinary in the way it has shaped his thought processes as well as his visual expression in art. Gifted Islam at birth, his introduction to the belief in the 'unseen' was the start of a long journey. To invoke or orient to the unseen, then is hardly a problem for one who carries this consciousness within quite unconsciously, by habit. In the absence of an externalized form, the acts of daily prayer perhaps help establish a relation with the intangible and the untouched, and in due course faith takes an edge over reason. Thus a consciousness of the power of the formless grew in Raza, which is articulated through words and symbols and reiterated through his works that visually reverberate as if with the magic of recitation and resonance. In Islam, there is also an engagement with the temporal, the unfinished sense of time. Human existence remains impermanent, unfixed and in the process of traversing destiny into an afterlife, and the human remains a musafir, a traveller who is pushed by the desire for a destination beyond the body and the material world. Something similar is reinforced in a line from the Upanishad, which says- "the eternal cannot be grasped, by the transient senses or the transient mind…!" The inadequacy of the body seeks spiritual engagements. In that sense, Raza has internalized the beauty of both Sufism and the Hindu philosophy- he can recite the Qoran and cite the Gita with equal passion. He says, " I am proud to be born a Muslim, and am equally proud of having studied under extraordinary Hindu teachers." The Hindu philosophical idea of dhyana, of darshan, of the Brahman and the Atman, all were deeply engaging for Raza who pursued ancient treatises on self and the universe with dedication. For Raza, the gesture of closing eyes in front of the deity evoked a similar feeling of 'turning within'. Later, Christianity came into his life with his wife and with Paris. The learning from these sources of inspiration has synthesized beautifully in Raza's art, his quest for the sublime form reinforcing the idea that spirituality and true knowledge transcend barriers and human divides invented in the name of religion.
Raza's work has always been about representing 'energy'. His artistic career began with an interest in capturing the immediate, the instantaneous moment of encounter with nature. As an ardent traveler- he traveled to different places- to the mountains and ghats, rivers and terrains, cities and countryside. Indeed outdoor locales were subjects painted in quick, brisk energetic strokes that captured the fleeting moods of nature or the momentum of urban life, dispersed in the encounters with the external environment. Raza wandered these 'outer' spaces to finally arrive at his 'inner' space of the intangible and the spiritual. Once in Paris, in 1953, the 'sense of the immediate' seemed to diminish, as if, Raza in his nostalgia of India, was mapping the distant, the unseen and the untouched -the Indian consciousness of centuries within the geometries of living that he carried within his mental folds. Choosing in his art, a non- representational mode, abstracting nature and existence into a geometry of colour and form perception, Raza moved away from empirical modalities and processes of analysis, routing his work in a spirituality that resonated with oriental flavor and colour. In departing from India and settling down in Paris, one witnesses the evolution to energy of a different kind- energy from latent sources- of memory, metaphors and mysticism. The concept of bindu and its anant sambhavna (myriad possibilities) subsumed him forever… To quote Raza, "As far as my work is concerned, I am coming to crystallization of a potent symbolism in its simplicity and elasticity. The process is continual and through elimination, my means are getting more and more economical and I am looking at my destination without the superfluous and the unnecessary."
Raza's works have often been categorized as abstract, but his paintings should not be ascribed to an 'art for art's sake' category, as they evolve in the context of themes that are deep-rooted in concepts of Indian philosophic thought. For Raza, the titles of his works are significant, and though he has stripped them of explicit narrative, meanings are not extinct within them. In fact, it is within this context that his non-objective imagery can be most appreciated. Condensed energy spills over from one painting to another, whether working with a magisterial sign of Bindu, the seed/ Ankuran or Kundalini. "For more than 55 years, I have been trying to articulate the infinite potentiality of the Bindu," says Raza. To him, Nature is contained with continual repetition and renewal. It is symbolic of life- forces and has been personified and celebrated in his art. In these recent series of works done in acrylic on canvas, Raza has explored aspects of femininity, its powers of creation in Kundalini, Germination, and Bindu- all painted in nuances of blue, indigo, black and white. He adds, " For this show, I am working with the theme of Nari Shakti, the creator rather than the created, exploring aspects of femininity and its latent energy of kundalini….the female form is far from being passive in Indian culture, where her innate powers are worshipped."
Space for Raza over the years, has become more and more non-objective as it turned away from ordinary consciousness and representations of seen reality. In his form making, space has become the ground plan, the receptacle, on which he paints his rhythmic breathing forms. His regular companions- the square and circle remain his preferred figures in geometry to begin with. The transformation of the two dimensional plane is gradual and graded as Raza layers over layer to liberate the visual form from the rigidity of the formal structure. In the process, form acquires presence, energy, light, airiness and the flutter of a transiting soul… The energies of line, colour, space and form flow into one another making concentric paths and creating an unbroken rhythm, a perpetual whisper if you will. His colours are like echoes, like verses of a prayer that reverberate. The potent nothingness/ darkness at the centre illuminates the edge, the outer rim radiating light, the Bindu (point) then becomes the Brahman (universe) in the act of expansion and contraction.
For Raza, the translation of spiritual evocation into painterly sensibilities has been of utmost importance. The bright colours, rhythmic lines and patterning of the Rajput and the Mughal miniatures, the symbolic hues and spatial planning of the Tantra, the emphasis on the 'inner rupa' rather than literalness of the outer form, have been significant insights for him in developing his language of painting. Raza remains deep in Indian thought, referencing Indian sources both in life and painting, polarizing the static and dynamic through spiritual hermeneutics.
The pursuit is endless in creating the 'formless in form' for in invoking the formless or the spiritual, there is no finality or totality. It is almost as necessary and routine as daily prayer, infused each time with a fresh hope of spiritual ascension and redemption. It is the power of endurance that is tested here, as the artist adopts the role of a sadhak immersed in his sadhna /meditation, spending years as if, sitting under a bodhi tree or then standing on the rock, in the need to conquer the temporal and the transient.
Manish Pushkale has been working on the concept of saamayik (which means japa or chanting) for the last three years. Manish works in oil on canvas with a minimum intervention of the brush to give the canvas a thinned colour bath. His entire process is worked out by the use of a cut-piece of fabric that acts as a sponge and absorbs the excess pigment and extra shine to impress the texture on to the surface, all by the process of taking away. This method comes real close to carving in sculpture where the form is shaped by subtracting the excess material or then in etching where the unnecessary is wiped off. Manish thins down the consistency of oil to the transparency of watercolour, applying layer upon layer till the desired effect is achieved. The painting emerges gradually…there is no apriori knowledge of its final shape and look. For Manish, his innovative methodology determines his process-oriented work.
In Manish, there is no extravagance of means - the elements themselves are frugal and there are many omissions practiced by him in his self-disciplining stance in front of the canvas. He strives for freedom within set restrictions. For instance, colour and line both are muted and toned down in his work. The artist wants to transcend the fixity and finiteness of space within the borders of his canvas. He desires the continuity and expansiveness of the experiential space- hence the creation of mirages, shadows and. shafts of light that trick the eye and the sense of touch, only to bring into focus, the illusory nature of things. One observes paths of light emanating from the grid like underlying structure that may have 9, 6 or 4 squares to begin with, but is superimposed with a succession of varying shapes on it. Space is energized by Manish through different directional and rotational pulls that result from the play of full and partial images through repeated and intuitive realization.
Indeed, space is hardly readymade for visual artists; they tailor it for desired ends. Raza and Manish both use the definiteness of certain shapes such as the square, triangle or circle but strive to transcend its limits and diagrammatic quality by stepping out of the grid (Manish) and creating a breathing rhythmic form. (Raza). Manish arrives at a brilliant visuality with his primary tool, the fabric fold, creating on the surface of the canvas, the illusion of folding and unfolding, veiling and unveiling spaces. For him, the many folds are more than a technical device- together with the fibers of fabric, they enrich the image, as Manish seeks poetry in a crease or tear transferred on the canvas. The exercise becomes intense for both of them as they seek fresh ways and means to transform finite forms to a metaphysical order.
It is interesting to me how Manish negates the objective reality in his meditative spaces, literally doing away with the object and retaining only their 'shadows' (though there are no shadows without objects) Released from their body and weight, the earthly dimensions of images/things are extracted to arrive at a sanyastha form. In the process, his work emanates transparency, airiness and a sense of open- ended movement through a rhythmic flow. The mystery of creation is negotiated in the play of shadow and spaces, in the gentle nuances of light and shifting viewpoints. The transference of impressed textures onto the canvas with subtlety creates the contrast of empty and occupied spaces, of depth and projection. The dichotomies of the spiritual and material, the inner and outer, are played out in the realm of the aesthetic adventure. Manish's colours are undefined, asocial and hardly ever symbolic. In their formal mediations, Raza and Manish have their own strengths. Raza's paintings dazzle with rich, saturated colours, Manish's canvases glow with soft, muted tones. The pictorial surface of Raza is animated by the tactility of paint while Manish works towards smooth, serene, reflective surfaces. Both Raza and Manish relinquish traces of individual ego and autobiographical narratives in seeking a higher revelation.
The Sufis elaborate upon the need to create an emptiness within, a condition of total receptivity for the nur (light of the Divine) to illuminate the centre within our being. The creative act becomes the means for the transference of inner energies into artistic forms, placing the artists repeatedly at the brink of a knowledge-empty and evacuated state, awaiting as if a spark from within to start afresh. In articulating the essence of the Bindu and Saamayik, Raza and Manish have overcome the lure of visible phenomena, exploring their shared spirit through chosen individual trajectories and struggles.
Roobina Karode
Art Historian
January 2004
S. H. RAZA
Solo Exhibitions
1947-1948 Bombay Art Society, Bombay
1950 Institute of Foreign Languages, Bombay
1958-1961-1962-1964-1967-1969 Galerie Lara Vincy, Paris
1959 Jehangir Art Gallery, Bombay
1959 AIFACS Gallery, New Delhi
1959-1960 Galerie Dresdnere, Montreal
1962-1968 Galerie Dresdnere, Toronto
1962 Lanyon Gallery, Palo Alto, California, USA
1962 Worth Ryder Art Gallery, Berekeley, University of California, California, USA
1963-1968 Dom Galerie, Cologne, Germany
1968 Tecta Galerie, Dusseldorf, Germany; Gallery Chemould, Bombay
1972 Abbaye du Pommier, Anncy, Le Grenier, Roquebrune-village
1974 La Palette, Trouville
1975 Galleria Matuzia, San Remo, Italy
1976 Jehangir Art Gallery, Gallery Chemould, Bombay; Stavanger Kunstforening Galerie, Norway
1977 La Tete de I'Art, Grenoble
1978 'Utsav', Madhya Pradesh Kala Parishad, Bhopal; Jehangir Nicholson Museum, National
Centre for Performing Arts, Bombay
1979 Stavanger Kunstforening, Norway
1980 Galleriet, Oslo
1982 Galerie Loeb, Bern, Switzerland; Galerie J.Y. Noblet, Grenoble
1984 Gallery Chemould, Bombay
1985 Galerie Pierre Parat, Paris
1987 La Tete de I'Art, Grenoble
1988 Gallery Chemould, Bombay; Galleri Koloritten, Stavanger, Norway
1990 Gallery Chemould, Bombay
1991 Galerie Eterso, Cannes; Retrospective: 1952-91, Palais Carnoles, Musee de Menton,
France
1992 Jehangir Nicholson Museum, National Centre for Performing Arts, Bombay; Parcours des
Arts, La Louvesc, France
1994 L'Artotheque d'Entreprise, Group Michel Ferrier, Echirolle, Grenoble
1997 Roopankar Museum of Fine Arts, Bharat Bhavan, Bhopal; Jehangir Art Gallery,
Mumbai; National Gallery of Modern Art, New Delhi
2002 Jehangir Art Gallery, Bomay
2003 The Fine Art Resource, Berlin
Group Exhibitions
1948 Progressive Artists Group, Bombay
1951 Salon de Mai, Paris
1952 Galerie Saint-Placide
1953 Galerie R. Creuze
1956 Biennale de Vencie; Les Arts en France et dans le Monde, Musee d'Art Moderne, Paris
1957 Biennale 57, Pavillion de Marsan, Paris; Exhibition organized by the Journal Asahi, Tokyo
Transferences, Zwemmer Gallery, London
1958 Biennale de Brugges; Biennale de Sao Paulo; Trends in Contemporary Painting from India,
Graham Gallery, New York; John Moore's Exhibition, Walker Art Gallery, Liverpool
1959 Gallery 59, Bombay
1960 Ecole de Paris 1960, Galerie Charpentier, Paris; Modern Indian Art, Santiago,
Trinidad and Mexico
1961 Ecole de Paris 61, Galerie Charpentier, Paris; Galerie Semiha Huber, Zurich
1962 Ecole de Paris 62, Galerie Charpentier, Paris; Werke der Ecole de Paris, Dom Galerie,
Cologne;Commonwealth Exhibition, Commonwealth Institute, London; Gallery 63, New York
Salon Comparaisons, Paris
1963 Grands et Jeunes d'Aujourd'hui, Paris; Salons Comparaisons, Paris; Biennale du Maroc,
Rabat
1964 Biennale de Menton
1965 Realites Nouvelles, Paris; Promesses tenues, Musee Galliera, Paris;
Art Now in India, Newcastle, UK
1966 Biennale de Menton; Salon Comparaisons, Paris
1967 Silver Jubilee Exhibition of Chemould, Bombay
1968 First Triennale, New Delhi; Biennale de Menton; Terres des Hommes,
Festival International, Montreal
1971 Recherche et Expression, Montermeil; Art et Fer Blanc, Paris
1972 Biennale de Menton; Realites Nouvelles, Salon Grands et Jeunes d'Aujourd'hui, Recherche
et Expression(Ploumanach, Orly, Paris); Gallerie d'Arte Pietra, Milan;
Wolfgang-Gurlitt Museum, Linz, Austria
1973 Estampes Contemporaines, Musee de Menton; Galleria Matuzia, San Remo;
Biliotheque Nationale, Paris; Indian Contemporary Painters, Renwich Gallery,
Washington; Pacific Cultural Museum, Pasadena, California, USA
1974 Premier Salon International d'Art Contemporain, Paris; Salon Grands et Jeunes
d'Aujourd'hui; Lalit Kala Akademi, New Delhi
1975 Sahel Palais de l'Europe, Menton
1976 Biennale de Menton
1977 Indiennes, Musee de Vire, Galleri Koloritten, Stavanger, Norway
1978 Pictorial Space, Lalit Kala Akademi, New Delhi; Salon de Dessin,
Paris; Vieux Presbitaire, Gorbio, L'Estampe Aujourd'hui, Bibliotheque Nationale;
Foire Internationale d'Art Contemporain, Grand Palais, Paris
1980 6 Kunstnere, Fra Syd-Franksike, Stavanger Kunstforening, Norway
1981 Charlottenborg, Copenhagen, Denmark
1982 Contemporary Indian Painting, Royal Academy, London;
'India, Myth & Reality', Aspects of Modern Indian Art,
Musesum of Modern Art, Oxford, UK
1983 Salon de Mai, Paris; Bibliotheque Nationale, Luxembourg
1984 J.Y. Noblet, Paris
1985 Artistes Indiens en France, Foundation Nationale des Arts Graphiques et Plastiques, Paris
1986 Contemporary Indian Art, Chester Herwitz Family Collection, Festival of India, Grey Gallery,
New York; Indian Art Today, The Phillip's Collection, Washington; Biennial,
Bharat Bhavan, Bhopal
1987 Galerie La Tete de I'Art, Grenoble; Biennial of Havana, Cuba; 'Coups de Coeur',
Halles de L'ille, Geneva, Switzerland; Contemporary Indian Art,
Christies Auction for Help-Age India, Bombay
1988 Maison de la Culture, Space Andre Malraux, Reims, France;
The National Museum of Contemporary Art, Olympiad, Seoul, Korea;
Art for CRY, Bombay, Bangalore, Calcutta, Delhi
1989 Salon de Mai, Grand Palais, Paris; Artistes Indiens a Paris, Galerie Cygne, Paris
1990 L'Artotheque d'Entreprise, Group Michel Ferrier, Echirolle, Grenoble
'Realite Seconde', Galerie Ariane, Paris
1991 'State of Art', Paintings with Computer, Jehangir Art Gallery,
Bombay; Ceramics, 'Faenza Anni of International Modern Art,
Calcutta; 'Indian Encounter',
Nehru Centre, London; 'Souvenir d'en France', Lalit Kala Galleries, New Delhi
1994 Salon de Mai, Espace Branley, Paris
1995 'Sept Peintres Indiens Contemporains', Le Monde de I'Art, Paris; Contemporary Indian Art,
Sotheby's, New York; Festival d'Avignon, France; Contemporary Indian Painting,
Christie's, London; 'Tree of my life', Village Gallery, New Delhi
1996-97 Contemporary Indian Painting, Sotheby's, New York; Harmony Show,
Nehru Centre, Bombay; 'Les Oceans', Metropolitaine, Lisbon, Portugal; 'Within the Frame',
Visual Art Centre, Hongkong; Progressive Artists Group, National Gallery of Modern Art,
Mumbai;'Chamatkar', The Indian Metaphor, Whitleys Art Gallery, London
1998 The Search
Within, Kloster Pernegg, Geras, Austria, and National Gallery of Modern Art,
New Delhi and Bombay
1999 Timeless Vision - Contemporary Art of India, Peabody Essex Museum,
Salem, Massachusetts
2000 Fukuoka Asian Art Museum, Fukuoka, Japan Arthur M. Sackler and
Freer Galleries of Art, Smithsonian Institute, Washington D.C.
2003 Des duos et des couples, Aix en Provence (with Pablo Picasso and Francoise Gillot)
and The Guild Art Gallery, Bombay
Museums
Musee National Art Moderne, Paris
Musee Art Moderne de la Ville de Paris
Musee de Grenoble
Baroda Museum, India
Tata Institute of Fundamental Research, Mumbai
Central Museum, Nagpur, India
Musee Ein-Arod, Israel
Asia Society, New York
Musee de Menton
Bibiliotheque Nationale, Paris
National Gallery of Modern Art, New Delhi
Jehangir Nicholson Museum, Mumbai
Musee Hors du Temps, Pierre-Feu Sur, Nice
Roopankar, Museum of Fine Arts, Bhopal
Lalit Kala Akademi, New Delhi
Centre for International Contemporary Arts, New York
Chester and Davida Herwitz Family Collection, Worcester, USA
L'Artotheque d'Entreprise, Group Michel Ferrier, Echirolles, France
Fonds Regional d'Art Contemporain, La Reunion
Fukuoka Art Museum, Japan
Awards
Raza was awarded the Prix de la Critique, in Paris, in 1956. He has been represented in the International Biennales at Venice, Sao Paulo and Menton and in the Triennale at New Delhi.
He was awarded the Padma Shri by the President of India in 1981 and was elected Fellow of Lalit Kala Akademi, New Delhi in 1983. He has also been awarded the Kalidas Samman, from the Madhya Pradesh Government.
MANISH PUSHKALE
Born : 1973, Bhopal
Solo Exhibitions :
1994-95 M.P. Kala Parishad, Bhopal
1997 Aurodhan, Bank of America, New Delhi
2003 Pundole Art Gallery, Mumbai
2003 Maison Des Sciences De L'Hommes - Paris
Two-man show:
2004 S.H. Raza and Manish Pushkale, The Guild Art Gallery, Mumbai
Group Exhibitions :
1999 Art from Land of Heart, Art Indus, New Delhi
"Red" Art Today, New Delhi
Group show, Alliance Francaise, Bhopal
Group show for Raza, Art Indus, New Delhi
Western Culture Zone, Udaipur
Lakeeren Gallery, Mumbai
2000 "Anadi", Chitrakala Parishad, Bangalore
"Anadi", Lalit Kala Academy, New Delhi
Rooprekha, exhibition of drawings, Lakshana Gallery, Hyderabad
Group show, Gallery TAO, Mumbai
Group show, curated by Renu Modi, Embassy of France, New Delhi
Group show, Gallery Espace, New Delhi
2001 "Anadi", National Gallery of Modern Art - Mumbai
"Anadi", Birla Academy, Calcutta
"Central Zone Show" - Gallery TAO, Mumbai, Show curated by Akhilesh
"Just another day, curated by Ratnottamma Sengupta, AIFACS, New Delhi
2002 ISHARA, Art Today, New Delhi
Twelve Artists, Gallery Espace, New Delhi
Harmony, curated by Vikram Sethi, Reliance Group, Mumbai
ARGOSY, curated by Renu Modi, Dubai, UAE
Group show, State Art Academy, Trichur
Group show, Trivendrum
2003 Seven, Travelling Exhibition of seven artists of different generations
Seven, Apparao Gallery, Chennai
Seven, TAO Gallery, Mumbai
Seven, Visual Art Gallery, New Delhi
2004 Seven, Time and Space Gallery, Bangalore
Young Contemporary artist, curated by Mala Aneja, Art Motif, New Delhi
Participation :
1997, 98 AIFACS Annual show, New Delhi
South Central Zone, Nagpur
Raza Exhibition, Bhopal
Kanagava International print Biennale, Japan
1998, 99 National Exhibition, Lalit Kala Academy, New Delhi
Kala Mela, New Delhi
Awards :
1997 AIFACS award
2000 Junior Research Fellowship, Govt. of India
2002 1st Bharat Bhawan Annual Exhibition, Certificate Award, Bhopal
2003 Raza Foundation Award
2003 Artist in Residence Award, Govt. of France
Camps :
1998 Artist Camp, Western Cultural Zone, Udaipur
1999 Artist Camp, AIFACS, New Delhi
1999 EPCO Camp, Bhopal
1999 INTACH, New Delhi
Others :
2002 Worked with Rajiv Sethi, for "Silk Route" Smithsonian festival, Washington DC, USA
2002 Executed a mural of 7' x 28' to the office of Foreign Secretary of India, Ministry of External Affairs, New Delhi
2003 Participated in auction conducted by Bowrings for "SAHAN", New Delhi
2003 Has keen featured in "Seven", a book written by Shri Ashok Vajpayee, on seven Indian Painters of different generations, published by Ravi Kumar Publishers, Paris
2004 Invited by Maison Des Sciences De L'hommes, for a lecture, Paris, France
Also involved in conservation and restoration of cultural property of India, worked in projects for conservation of "Bagore Ki Haveli" Udaipur, Deewane - Khas, Red Fort, New Delhi
Collections :
"Museum of Western Cultural Centre, Udaipur
S.H. Raza Foundation, Paris
The Times of India, New Delhi
Office of Chief Secretary, Govt. of M.P., Bhopal
Birla Academy, Calcutta
French Cultural Centre, New Delhi
Ministry of External Affairs, New Delhi
Maison De Sciences De L'hommes, Paris
Ranbaxy Pharmaceuticals, New Delhi
Vidhan Sabha Bhawan, Bhopal
Asian Academy of Films and T.V., New Delhi
|
&des='Oil+on+canvas,+2004'&folder=Images/ManishPushkale/MP-5.jpg&freight=3500&price=00)
